awt logo

DEM Council Member_36th Council District (NYC; 2021-06-22)

🔗 2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District     (tags: { 2021 , from-bolson , actual , NY , NYC-2021 , NYC_NY , 2021-06 })

Below is the ABIF from the "2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District" election (DEM Council Member_36th Council District (NYC; 2021-06-22))

ABIF submission area (show)
Method options
Ballot options

Voting methods: IRV • FPTP • approval • STAR • Pairwise • All methods

Results

🔗https://abif.electorama.com/id/2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District

Below are the results of the election represented above using various election methods with abiftool/abiflib. The detected ballot type from the ABIF above is "ranked". Some methods may transform these ballots for analysis; see method notices for details. Resubmit the ABIF with "Transform ballots" turned off to minimize the transformations.

Method Winner
IRV/RCV Chi A. Osse
FPTP Chi A. Osse
Approval Tahirah A. Moore
STAR Chi A. Osse
Condorcet/Copeland Chi A. Osse
Election results summary showing voting method winners
click/tap to expand
tabbed view

IRV/RCV results

2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District IRV/RCV result permalink:
🔗https://abif.electorama.com/id/2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District/IRV#IRV

  • IRV/RCV Winner: Chi A. Osse with 11,168 votes (48.0%) in final round
  • Runner-up: Henry L. Butler with 8,422 votes (36.2%) in final round
  • Exhausted ballots in final round: 3,654 (15.7%)
  • Number of rounds: 4
  • Ballots counted in final round: 19,590 (84.3%)
  • Majority of ballots: 11,623 (50.0%)
  • Total ballots: 23,244
Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4
Overview:
Active ballots: 23,244 (100.0%)

Exhausted ballots: 0 (0.0%)
Counted ballots: 23,244 (100.0%)
Overview:
Active ballots: 23,244 (100.0%)

Exhausted ballots: 204 (0.9%)
Counted ballots: 23,040 (99.1%)
Winning threshold: 11,521 (49.57%)
 		Overview:
Active ballots: 23,244 (100.0%)

Exhausted ballots: 1,499 (6.4%)
Counted ballots: 21,745 (93.6%)
Winning threshold: 10,873 (46.78%)
 		Overview:
Active ballots: 23,244 (100.0%)

Exhausted ballots: 3,654 (15.7%)
Counted ballots: 19,590 (84.3%)
Winning threshold: 9,796 (42.14%)
Chi A. Osse: 8,540 (36.7%)
→
 Chi A. Osse: 8,639 (37.2%)
→
 Chi A. Osse: 9,026 (38.8%)
→
 IRV/RCV winner:
Chi A. Osse: 11,168 (48.0%)✅
→
Henry L. Butler: 5,445 (23.4%)
→
 Henry L. Butler: 5,567 (24.0%)
→
 Henry L. Butler: 6,513 (28.0%)
→
 Henry L. Butler: 8,422 (36.2%) (🛑eliminated)
→
Tahirah A. Moore: 5,345 (23.0%)
→
 Tahirah A. Moore: 5,487 (23.6%)
→
 Tahirah A. Moore: 6,206 (26.7%) (🛑eliminated)
→
 Tahirah A. Moore
Robert Waterman: 3,267 (14.1%)
→
 Robert Waterman: 3,347 (14.4%) (🛑eliminated)
→
 Robert Waterman Robert Waterman
Reginald Swiney: 647 (2.8%) (🛑eliminated)
→
 Reginald Swiney Reginald Swiney Reginald Swiney

FPTP result

"FPTP" is "First-past-the-post", also known as "plurality" or "choose-one"
2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District FPTP results permalink:
🔗https://abif.electorama.com/id/2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District/FPTP#FPTP
📝
Note — Only using first-choices on ranked ballots

  • FPTP Winner: Chi A. Osse with 8,540 first-place votes (36.7%)
  • Runner-up: Henry L. Butler with 5,445 first-place votes (23.4%)
  • Margin of victory: 3,095 votes (13.3 percentage points)
  • First-place votes
    • Chi A. Osse: 8,540 votes (36.7 %)
    • Henry L. Butler: 5,445 votes (23.4 %)
    • Tahirah A. Moore: 5,345 votes (23.0 %)
    • Robert Waterman: 3,267 votes (14.1 %)
    • Reginald Swiney: 647 votes (2.8 %)
  • Total ballots: 23,244

Approval voting results

2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District approval voting results permalink:
🔗https://abif.electorama.com/id/2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District/approval#approval
📝
Note — Approval counts estimated from 23,244 ranked ballots using favorite_viable_half method
Details

The 'favorite_viable_half' conversion algorithm: find the candidate with the most first preferences, and then determine the minimum number of figurative seats that would need to be open in order for the candidate to exceed the Hare quota with the given first-prefs. We use this to estimate how many candidates are likely to be viable candidates.

Using first-choice vote totals as a rough guide, approximately 3 candidates appear viable: Chi A. Osse, Henry L. Butler, and Tahirah A. Moore. The approximation then assumes each voter approves up to 2 of their top-ranked viable candidates (half of 3, rounded up). All candidates ranked at or above the lowest-ranked of each ballot's top viable candidates receive approval (considering up to 2 viable candidates per ballot).

See transformed ballots

Note: For Approval, these choose_many ballots are inferred from ranked ballots.

Conversion method: favorite_viable_half

#------- metadata -------
{ballotcount: 23244}
{version: "0.1"}
{ballotcount_abif_metadata: "23244"}
{is_ranking_to_rating: true}
#------ candlines ------
=[Chi A. Osse]:[Chi A. Osse]
=[Tahirah A. Moore]:[Tahirah A. Moore]
=[Henry L. Butler]:[Henry L. Butler]
=[Robert Waterman]:[Robert Waterman]
=[Reginald Swiney]:[Reginald Swiney]
#------- votelines ------
2533:[Chi A. Osse]/1
1882:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1744:[Henry L. Butler]/1
1607:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
705:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
584:[Chi A. Osse]/1
377:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
366:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
363:[Henry L. Butler]/1
332:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
312:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
237:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
202:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
202:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
174:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
173:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
172:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
159:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
154:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
151:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
147:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
140:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
139:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
129:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
125:[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
120:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
117:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
114:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
113:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
112:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
100:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
98:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
96:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
95:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
95:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
94:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
94:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
93:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
89:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
88:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
86:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
86:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
84:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
84:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
81:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
80:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
80:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
79:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
77:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
76:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
75:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
74:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
72:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
71:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
70:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
69:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
68:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
68:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
67:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
66:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
65:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
65:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
64:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
63:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
63:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
63:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
61:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
61:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
61:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
60:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
59:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
58:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
57:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
57:[Henry L. Butler]/1
57:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
56:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
56:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
56:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
55:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
55:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
55:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
54:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
53:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
52:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
51:[Henry L. Butler]/1
47:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
46:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
45:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
45:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
45:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
45:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
44:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
44:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
44:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
42:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
41:[Chi A. Osse]/1
40:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
40:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
39:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
38:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
37:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
36:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
36:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
36:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
36:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
36:[Chi A. Osse]/1
36:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
35:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
35:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
35:[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
35:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
34:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
34:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
34:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
33:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
33:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
32:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
31:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
31:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
30:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
30:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
28:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
28:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
27:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
27:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
27:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
27:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
26:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
24:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
24:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
24:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
24:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
24:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
23:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
23:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
22:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
22:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
22:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
22:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
21:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
21:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
21:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
21:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
20:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
20:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
20:[Henry L. Butler]/1
19:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
19:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
19:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
19:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
19:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
19:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
18:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
18:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
18:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
18:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
18:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
18:[Henry L. Butler]/1
18:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
17:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
17:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
17:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
17:[Henry L. Butler]/1
17:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
17:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
17:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
17:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
17:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
17:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
16:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
15:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
15:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
15:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
15:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
15:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
15:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
14:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
14:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
14:[Chi A. Osse]/1
14:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
14:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
13:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
13:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
13:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
13:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
13:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
12:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
12:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
12:[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
12:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
12:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
12:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
12:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
11:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
11:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
11:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
11:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
11:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
11:[Chi A. Osse]/1
11:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
11:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
11:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
10:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
10:[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
10:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
10:[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
10:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
10:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
10:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
9:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
9:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
9:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
9:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
9:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
9:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
9:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
9:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
8:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
8:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
8:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
8:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
8:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
8:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
7:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
7:[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
7:[Henry L. Butler]/1
7:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
7:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
7:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
7:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
7:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
7:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
7:[Chi A. Osse]/1
7:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
7:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
7:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
7:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
7:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
6:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
6:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
6:[Henry L. Butler]/1
6:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
6:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
6:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
6:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
6:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
6:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
6:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
6:[Henry L. Butler]/1
5:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
5:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
5:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
5:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
5:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
5:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
5:[Henry L. Butler]/1
5:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
5:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
5:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
5:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
5:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
5:[Henry L. Butler]/1
5:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
5:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
5:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
4:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
3:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
3:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
2:[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
2:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
2:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Robert Waterman]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Henry L. Butler]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Henry L. Butler]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Reginald Swiney]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
1:[Chi A. Osse]/1=[Tahirah A. Moore]/1
  • Approval Winner: Tahirah A. Moore
  • Approval Results:
    • Tahirah A. Moore — 13,015 approvals (55.99% of ballots) (✅ winner)
    • Chi A. Osse — 12,578 approvals (54.11% of ballots)
    • Henry L. Butler — 9,773 approvals (42.05% of ballots)
    • Robert Waterman — 4,022 approvals (17.3% of ballots)
    • Reginald Swiney — 1,929 approvals (8.3% of ballots)
  • Total: 23,244 ballots (41,317 total approvals)

STAR results

2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District STAR results permalink:
🔗https://abif.electorama.com/id/2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District/STAR#STAR
📝
Note — STAR ratings estimated from ranked ballots using Borda scoring method
Details

The ranked ballots have been converted to STAR ratings using Borda scoring: each candidate receives points equal to (number_of_candidates - their_rank). In this election, we have 5 candidates, so the 1st choice gets 4 points, the 2nd choice gets 3 points, etc. These Borda scores are then used as STAR ratings for tabulation by STAR.

  • STAR winner: Chi A. Osse
  • Finalists: Chi A. Osse vs Tahirah A. Moore
  • Runoff result:
    • Chi A. Osse: 10,436 votes (44.9%)
    • Tahirah A. Moore: 8,707 votes (37.5%)
    • No preference: 4101 voters (17.6%)
  • Total stars allocated: 167,126
  • Total ballots: 23,244
★★★★★★

★★★★★

★★★★★★
★★★★★
★★★★★★
★★★★★
★★★★★★
★★★★★
★★★★★★
(one star above is approximately 3,343 stars allocated by voters)
  • First round:
    • ★#0: Chi A. Osse received 46,505 stars (27.8%) from 13,843 voters (59.6%)
    • ★#1: Tahirah A. Moore received 44,116 stars (26.4%) from 14,360 voters (61.8%)
    • ★#2: Henry L. Butler received 36,284 stars (21.7%) from 11,860 voters (51.0%)
    • ★#3: Robert Waterman received 28,911 stars (17.3%) from 10,474 voters (45.1%)
    • ★#4: Reginald Swiney received 11,310 stars (6.8%) from 5,416 voters (23.3%)
  • Finalists:
    • ★Chi A. Osse (✅ winner) preferred by 10,436 of 23,244 voters
    • ★Tahirah A. Moore preferred by 8,707 of 23,244 voters
    • ★No preference between the finalists: 4101

NOTE: Since ratings or stars are not present in the provided ballots, allocated stars are estimated using a Borda-like formula.

Condorcet/Copeland results

2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District Condorcet/Copeland results permalink:
🔗https://abif.electorama.com/id/2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District/pairwise#pairwise
  • Winner: Chi A. Osse
  • Runner-up: Tahirah A. Moore (beats all other candidates except Chi A. Osse)
  • Smallest margin: Henry L. Butler over Robert Waterman (9,171-6,686; margin: 2,485)
  • Largest margin: Tahirah A. Moore over Reginald Swiney (13,159-2,250; margin: 10,909)
  • Pairwise ties: none
  • Total ballots: 23,244

Win-loss-tie (Condorcet/Copeland) table

2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District w-l-t table permalink:
🔗https://abif.electorama.com/id/2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District/pairwise#wlt
DEM Council Member_36th Council District (NYC; 2021-06-22) pairwise matchups
Chi A. Osse
(4-0-0)
Chi A. Osse
4 victories ⇣
Tahirah A. Moore
(3-1-0)
Chi A. Osse: 10,436(44.9%)
Tahirah A. Moore: 8,707(37.5%)
(No preference: 4,101; 17.6%)
Tahirah A. Moore
⇽ 1 loss / 3 victories† ⇣
Henry L. Butler
(2-2-0)
Chi A. Osse: 11,168(48.0%)
Henry L. Butler: 8,422(36.2%)
(No preference: 3,654; 15.7%)
Tahirah A. Moore: 10,514(45.2%)
Henry L. Butler: 7,864(33.8%)
(No preference: 4,866; 20.9%)
Henry L. Butler
⇽ 2 losses / 2 victories† ⇣
Robert Waterman
(1-3-0)
Chi A. Osse: 11,983(51.6%)
Robert Waterman: 6,630(28.5%)
(No preference: 4,631; 19.9%)
Tahirah A. Moore: 11,736(50.5%)
Robert Waterman: 6,180(26.6%)
(No preference: 5,328; 22.9%)
Henry L. Butler: 9,171(39.5%)
Robert Waterman: 6,686(28.8%)
(No preference: 7,387; 31.8%)
Robert Waterman
⇽ 3 losses / 1 victory† ⇣
Reginald Swiney
(0-4-0)
Chi A. Osse: 12,918(55.6%)
Reginald Swiney: 3,423(14.7%)
(No preference: 6,903; 29.7%)
Tahirah A. Moore: 13,159(56.6%)
Reginald Swiney: 2,250(9.7%)
(No preference: 7,835; 33.7%)
Henry L. Butler: 10,827(46.6%)
Reginald Swiney: 2,510(10.8%)
(No preference: 9,907; 42.6%)
Robert Waterman: 9,415(40.5%)
Reginald Swiney: 3,127(13.5%)
(No preference: 10,702; 46.0%)

Pairwise tournament (Copeland ordered)

2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District pairwise diagram permalink:
🔗https://abif.electorama.com/id/2021-06-22_NYC-PE2021_CVR_Final-DEM_Council_Member_36th_Council_District/pairwise#dot

%3 Chi A. Osse Chi A. Osse 4-0-0 (4 wins, 0 losses, 0 ties) Tahirah A. Moore Tahirah A. Moore 3-1-0 Chi A. Osse->Tahirah A. Moore ← Chi A. Osse: 10436 Tahirah A. Moore: 8707 Henry L. Butler Henry L. Butler 2-2-0 Chi A. Osse->Henry L. Butler ← Chi A. Osse: 11168 Henry L. Butler: 8422 Robert Waterman Robert Waterman 1-3-0 Chi A. Osse->Robert Waterman ← Chi A. Osse: 11983 Robert Waterman: 6630 Reginald Swiney Reginald Swiney 0-4-0 Chi A. Osse->Reginald Swiney ← Chi A. Osse: 12918 Reginald Swiney: 3423 Tahirah A. Moore->Henry L. Butler ← Tahirah A. Moore: 10514 Henry L. Butler: 7864 Tahirah A. Moore->Robert Waterman ← Tahirah A. Moore: 11736 Robert Waterman: 6180 Tahirah A. Moore->Reginald Swiney ← Tahirah A. Moore: 13159 Reginald Swiney: 2250 Henry L. Butler->Robert Waterman ← Henry L. Butler: 9171 Robert Waterman: 6686 Henry L. Butler->Reginald Swiney ← Henry L. Butler: 10827 Reginald Swiney: 2510 Robert Waterman->Reginald Swiney ← Robert Waterman: 9415 Reginald Swiney: 3127

Voting methods: IRV • FPTP • approval • STAR • Pairwise • All methods

(homepage)

awt logo
abif.electorama.com is maintained as part of the electorama.com family of websites.
Source code: github.com/electorama/abiftool (for the core library) and github.com/electorama/awt (for the web presentation code)
Bug reports: github.com/electorama/awt/issues
Copyright © 2024, 2025 by Rob Lanphier — All Rights Reserved. Licensed under the AGPL 3.0.
awt logo