Debian 2010 Project Leader
Below is the ABIF from the "DPL2010" election (Debian 2010 Project Leader)
Voting methods: IRV β’ FPTP β’ approval β’ STAR β’ Pairwise β’ All methods
Results
Below are the results of the election represented above using various election methods with abiftool/abiflib. The detected ballot type from the ABIF above is "ranked". Some methods may transform these ballots for analysis; see method notices for details. Resubmit the ABIF with "Transform ballots" turned off to minimize the transformations.
| Method | Winner |
|---|---|
| IRV/RCV | Stefano Zacchiroli |
| FPTP | Stefano Zacchiroli |
| Approval | Stefano Zacchiroli |
| STAR | Stefano Zacchiroli |
| Condorcet/Copeland | Stefano Zacchiroli |
IRV/RCV results
πhttps://abif.electorama.com/id/DPL2010/IRV#IRV
- IRV/RCV Winner: Stefano Zacchiroli with 228 votes (52.3%) in final round
- Runner-up: Margarita Manterola with 97 votes (22.2%) in final round
- Exhausted ballots in final round: 35 (8.0%)
- Number of rounds: 1
- Ballots counted in final round: 401 (92.0%)
- Majority of ballots: 219 (50.2%)
- Total ballots: 436
| Round 1 |
|---|
| Overview: Active ballots: 436 (100.0%) Exhausted ballots: 0 (0.0%) Overvotes: 35 (8.0%) Counted ballots: 401 (92.0%) Winning threshold: 201 (46.10%) |
| IRV/RCV winner: Stefano Zacchiroli: 228 (52.3%)β β
|
|
Margarita Manterola: 97 (22.2%)
(πeliminated)
β
|
|
Wouter Verhelst: 60 (13.8%)
(πeliminated)
β
|
|
Charles Plessy: 11 (2.5%)
(πeliminated)
β
|
|
None Of The Above: 5 (1.1%)
(πeliminated)
β
|
Overvotes are ballots where multiple candidates are ranked at the same, highest-ranking position.
FPTP result
DPL2010 FPTP results permalink:
πhttps://abif.electorama.com/id/DPL2010/FPTP#FPTP
- FPTP Winner: Stefano Zacchiroli with 228 first-place votes (52.3%)
- Runner-up: Margarita Manterola with 97 first-place votes (22.2%)
- Margin of victory: 131 votes (30.0 percentage points)
- First-place votes
- Stefano Zacchiroli: 228 votes (52.3 %)
- Margarita Manterola: 97 votes (22.2 %)
- Wouter Verhelst: 60 votes (13.8 %)
- Charles Plessy: 11 votes (2.5 %)
- None Of The Above: 5 votes (1.1 %)
- Overvotes: 35 (8.0 %)
- Total ballots: 436
Approval voting results
πhttps://abif.electorama.com/id/DPL2010/approval#approval
See transformed ballots
Note: For Approval, these choose_many ballots are inferred from ranked ballots.
Conversion method: favorite_viable_half
#------- metadata -------
{ballotcount: 436}
{ballotcount_abif_metadata: "436"}
{description: "2010 Debian Project Leader election, won by Stefano Zacchiroli"}
{is_ranking_to_rating: true}
#------ candlines ------
=StefanoZacchiroli:[Stefano Zacchiroli]
=WouterVerhelst:[Wouter Verhelst]
=CharlesPlessy:[Charles Plessy]
=MargaritaManterola:[Margarita Manterola]
=NOTA:[None Of The Above]
#------- votelines ------
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:NOTA/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=NOTA/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:NOTA/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:NOTA/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=MargaritaManterola/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
1:MargaritaManterola/1
1:CharlesPlessy/1=StefanoZacchiroli/1=WouterVerhelst/1
1:StefanoZacchiroli/1
- Approval Winner: Stefano Zacchiroli
- Approval Results:
- Stefano Zacchiroli (StefanoZacchiroli) — 274 approvals (62.84% of ballots) (β winner)
- Margarita Manterola (MargaritaManterola) — 120 approvals (27.52% of ballots)
- Wouter Verhelst (WouterVerhelst) — 61 approvals (13.99% of ballots)
- Charles Plessy (CharlesPlessy) — 16 approvals (3.67% of ballots)
- None Of The Above (NOTA) — 4 approvals (0.92% of ballots)
- Total: 436 ballots (475 total approvals)
STAR results
πhttps://abif.electorama.com/id/DPL2010/STAR#STAR
- STAR winner: Stefano Zacchiroli
- Finalists: Stefano Zacchiroli vs Margarita Manterola
- Runoff result:
- Stefano Zacchiroli: 271 votes (62.2%)
- Margarita Manterola: 124 votes (28.4%)
- No preference: 41 voters (9.4%)
- Total stars allocated: 4,548
- Total ballots: 436
- First round:
- β #0: Stefano Zacchiroli received 1,414 stars (31.1%) from 408 voters (93.6%)
- β #1: Margarita Manterola received 1,143 stars (25.1%) from 400 voters (91.7%)
- β #2: Wouter Verhelst received 1,099 stars (24.2%) from 403 voters (92.4%)
- β #3: Charles Plessy received 493 stars (10.8%) from 278 voters (63.8%)
- β #4: None Of The Above received 399 stars (8.8%) from 237 voters (54.4%)
- Finalists:
- β Stefano Zacchiroli (β winner) preferred by 271 of 436 voters
- β Margarita Manterola preferred by 124 of 436 voters
- β No preference between the finalists: 41
NOTE: Since ratings or stars are not present in the provided ballots, allocated stars are estimated using a Borda-like formula.
Condorcet/Copeland results
πhttps://abif.electorama.com/id/DPL2010/pairwise#pairwise
- Winner: Stefano Zacchiroli
- Runner-up: Margarita Manterola (beats all other candidates except Stefano Zacchiroli)
- Smallest margin: Margarita Manterola over Wouter Verhelst (207-177; margin: 30)
- Largest margin: Stefano Zacchiroli over None Of The Above (395-28; margin: 367)
- Pairwise ties: none
- Total ballots: 436
Win-loss-tie (Condorcet/Copeland) table
πhttps://abif.electorama.com/id/DPL2010/pairwise#wlt
|
Stefano Zacchiroli
(4-0-0)
|
Stefano Zacchiroli
4 victories β£ |
|||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Margarita Manterola
(3-1-0)
|
Stefano Zacchiroli:
271(62.2%)
Margarita Manterola:
124(28.4%)
(No preference: 41; 9.4%)
|
Margarita Manterola
β½ 1 loss / 3 victoriesβ β£ |
||
|
Wouter Verhelst
(2-2-0)
|
Stefano Zacchiroli:
300(68.8%)
Wouter Verhelst:
102(23.4%)
(No preference: 34; 7.8%)
|
Margarita Manterola:
207(47.5%)
Wouter Verhelst:
177(40.6%)
(No preference: 52; 11.9%)
|
Wouter Verhelst
β½ 2 losses / 2 victoriesβ β£ |
|
|
Charles Plessy
(1-3-0)
|
Stefano Zacchiroli:
373(85.6%)
Charles Plessy:
33(7.6%)
(No preference: 30; 6.9%)
|
Margarita Manterola:
332(76.1%)
Charles Plessy:
53(12.2%)
(No preference: 51; 11.7%)
|
Wouter Verhelst:
334(76.6%)
Charles Plessy:
47(10.8%)
(No preference: 55; 12.6%)
|
Charles Plessy
β½ 3 losses / 1 victoryβ β£ |
|
None Of The Above
(0-4-0)
|
Stefano Zacchiroli:
395(90.6%)
None Of The Above:
28(6.4%)
(No preference: 13; 3.0%)
|
Margarita Manterola:
366(83.9%)
None Of The Above:
48(11.0%)
(No preference: 22; 5.0%)
|
Wouter Verhelst:
375(86.0%)
None Of The Above:
39(8.9%)
(No preference: 22; 5.0%)
|
Charles Plessy:
217(49.8%)
None Of The Above:
183(42.0%)
(No preference: 36; 8.3%)
|
Pairwise tournament (Copeland ordered)
πhttps://abif.electorama.com/id/DPL2010/pairwise#dot
Voting methods: IRV β’ FPTP β’ approval β’ STAR β’ Pairwise β’ All methods
(homepage)