Board of Supervisors District 10 (SanFrancisco; 2014-11-04)

🔗 2014-11-04_SanFrancisco-Board_of_Supervisors_District_10 (tags: { SanFrancisco-2014 , from-bolson , actual , SF , 2014 , SanFrancisco_CA , 2014-11 , CA })

Below is the ABIF from the "2014-11-04_SanFrancisco-Board_of_Supervisors_District_10" election (Board of Supervisors District 10 (SanFrancisco; 2014-11-04))

ABIF submission area (show)

#------- metadata -------
{version: "0.1"}
{ballotcount: 16342}
#------ candlines ------
=[TONY KELLY]:[TONY KELLY]
=[MARLENE TRAN]:[MARLENE TRAN]
=[ED DONALDSON]:[ED DONALDSON]
=[SHAWN M. RICHARD]:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
=[MALIA COHEN]:[MALIA COHEN]
#------- votelines ------
1755:[MALIA COHEN]
1013:[MALIA COHEN]
897:
687:[TONY KELLY]
549:[MARLENE TRAN]
542:[MALIA COHEN]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[TONY KELLY]
534:[TONY KELLY]>[MALIA COHEN]
450:[MARLENE TRAN]>[MALIA COHEN]>[TONY KELLY]
448:[MALIA COHEN]>[TONY KELLY]
426:[TONY KELLY]>[ED DONALDSON]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
406:[MALIA COHEN]>[TONY KELLY]>[MARLENE TRAN]
378:[MALIA COHEN]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
351:[TONY KELLY]
308:[MALIA COHEN]>[TONY KELLY]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
308:[MARLENE TRAN]
280:[MALIA COHEN]>[MARLENE TRAN]
258:[MALIA COHEN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[TONY KELLY]
254:[MARLENE TRAN]>[MALIA COHEN]
243:[TONY KELLY]>[MALIA COHEN]>[MARLENE TRAN]
237:[MALIA COHEN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MARLENE TRAN]
235:[MALIA COHEN]>[TONY KELLY]>[ED DONALDSON]
235:[MALIA COHEN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[ED DONALDSON]
220:[MARLENE TRAN]>[TONY KELLY]>[MALIA COHEN]
210:[MARLENE TRAN]>[MALIA COHEN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
195:[MALIA COHEN]>[ED DONALDSON]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
173:[MALIA COHEN]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[ED DONALDSON]
159:[MALIA COHEN]>[ED DONALDSON]>[TONY KELLY]
142:[TONY KELLY]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[MALIA COHEN]
130:[TONY KELLY]>[MALIA COHEN]>[ED DONALDSON]
129:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[ED DONALDSON]>[TONY KELLY]
127:[TONY KELLY]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[ED DONALDSON]
126:[TONY KELLY]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[ED DONALDSON]
126:[TONY KELLY]>[MALIA COHEN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
124:[ED DONALDSON]
119:[TONY KELLY]>[ED DONALDSON]>[MARLENE TRAN]
115:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
113:[TONY KELLY]>[ED DONALDSON]
109:[MARLENE TRAN]>[TONY KELLY]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
102:[TONY KELLY]>[ED DONALDSON]>[MALIA COHEN]
99:[TONY KELLY]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
97:[MARLENE TRAN]>[TONY KELLY]
93:[ED DONALDSON]>[TONY KELLY]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
89:[MARLENE TRAN]>[TONY KELLY]>[ED DONALDSON]
89:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MALIA COHEN]>[TONY KELLY]
89:[MALIA COHEN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
88:[MALIA COHEN]>[ED DONALDSON]>[MARLENE TRAN]
85:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
83:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MALIA COHEN]>[ED DONALDSON]
82:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MALIA COHEN]>[MARLENE TRAN]
80:[TONY KELLY]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MARLENE TRAN]
80:[ED DONALDSON]
76:[TONY KELLY]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MALIA COHEN]
72:[ED DONALDSON]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[TONY KELLY]
71:[TONY KELLY]>[MALIA COHEN]
61:[MALIA COHEN]>[TONY KELLY]
60:[TONY KELLY]>[MARLENE TRAN]
58:[MALIA COHEN]>[ED DONALDSON]
58:[MARLENE TRAN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[TONY KELLY]
58:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[TONY KELLY]>[ED DONALDSON]
52:[MARLENE TRAN]>[MALIA COHEN]>[ED DONALDSON]
51:[MARLENE TRAN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MALIA COHEN]
51:[MALIA COHEN]>[MARLENE TRAN]
50:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[TONY KELLY]>[MALIA COHEN]
50:[MALIA COHEN]
49:[ED DONALDSON]>[MALIA COHEN]>[TONY KELLY]
47:[ED DONALDSON]>[MALIA COHEN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
45:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[TONY KELLY]
44:[MARLENE TRAN]>[ED DONALDSON]>[TONY KELLY]
44:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[ED DONALDSON]>[MALIA COHEN]
43:[MARLENE TRAN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[ED DONALDSON]
42:[ED DONALDSON]>[TONY KELLY]>[MALIA COHEN]
39:[MARLENE TRAN]>[ED DONALDSON]>[MALIA COHEN]
37:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[MALIA COHEN]
37:[ED DONALDSON]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MALIA COHEN]
37:[MARLENE TRAN]>[MALIA COHEN]
36:[ED DONALDSON]>[TONY KELLY]>[MARLENE TRAN]
35:[MALIA COHEN]>[MARLENE TRAN]
33:[MALIA COHEN]>[TONY KELLY]
33:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[ED DONALDSON]>[MARLENE TRAN]
31:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MALIA COHEN]
30:[MARLENE TRAN]>[ED DONALDSON]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
27:[MARLENE TRAN]
27:[ED DONALDSON]>[TONY KELLY]
25:[ED DONALDSON]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[TONY KELLY]
24:[ED DONALDSON]>[MALIA COHEN]
22:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MALIA COHEN]
22:[TONY KELLY]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
20:[ED DONALDSON]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MARLENE TRAN]
20:[ED DONALDSON]>[MALIA COHEN]
19:[ED DONALDSON]>[MALIA COHEN]>[MARLENE TRAN]
18:[ED DONALDSON]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
18:[ED DONALDSON]>[TONY KELLY]
18:[TONY KELLY]>[MARLENE TRAN]
17:[TONY KELLY]>[MALIA COHEN]
17:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[ED DONALDSON]
16:[MALIA COHEN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
16:[MARLENE TRAN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
15:[MARLENE TRAN]>[TONY KELLY]
15:[TONY KELLY]
15:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[TONY KELLY]
15:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[TONY KELLY]>[MARLENE TRAN]
15:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MALIA COHEN]
14:[ED DONALDSON]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
14:[MALIA COHEN]>[ED DONALDSON]
14:[ED DONALDSON]>[MARLENE TRAN]>[MALIA COHEN]
14:[ED DONALDSON]
14:[MALIA COHEN]>[ED DONALDSON]
13:[TONY KELLY]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
13:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[ED DONALDSON]
13:[TONY KELLY]>[ED DONALDSON]
12:[ED DONALDSON]>[MALIA COHEN]
11:[MALIA COHEN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
11:[ED DONALDSON]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
10:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[ED DONALDSON]
9:[MARLENE TRAN]>[MALIA COHEN]
8:[TONY KELLY]>[ED DONALDSON]
7:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[TONY KELLY]
7:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
7:[MARLENE TRAN]>[TONY KELLY]
6:[ED DONALDSON]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
5:[MARLENE TRAN]>[ED DONALDSON]
5:[MARLENE TRAN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
4:[ED DONALDSON]>[MARLENE TRAN]
4:[TONY KELLY]>[MARLENE TRAN]
4:[ED DONALDSON]>[TONY KELLY]
4:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[ED DONALDSON]
4:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MARLENE TRAN]
4:[MARLENE TRAN]>[ED DONALDSON]
3:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[TONY KELLY]
3:[MARLENE TRAN]>[SHAWN M. RICHARD]
3:[SHAWN M. RICHARD]>[MARLENE TRAN]
2:[ED DONALDSON]>[MARLENE TRAN]
1:[MARLENE TRAN]>[ED DONALDSON]
1:[ED DONALDSON]>[MARLENE TRAN]

Method options

FPTP results?

IRV/RCV results?

IRV extra analysis?

Approval results?

STAR results?

pairwise (Condorcet/Copeland) results?

pairwise tournament diagram?

Ballot options Transform ballots (using ballot-type metadata)?

Voting methods: IRV • FPTP • approval • STAR • Pairwise • All methods

Results

🔗https://abif.electorama.com/id/2014-11-04_SanFrancisco-Board_of_Supervisors_District_10

The STAR results of 2014-11-04_SanFrancisco-Board_of_Supervisors_District_10 are below, and can be edited in the field above.

Method	Winner
STAR	MALIA COHEN

OFF ON tabbed view

STAR results

2014-11-04_SanFrancisco-Board_of_Supervisors_District_10 STAR results permalink:
🔗https://abif.electorama.com/id/2014-11-04_SanFrancisco-Board_of_Supervisors_District_10/STAR#STAR

📝

Note — STAR ratings estimated from ranked ballots using Borda scoring method

Details

The ranked ballots have been converted to STAR ratings using Borda scoring: each candidate receives points equal to (number_of_candidates - their_rank). In this election, we have 5 candidates, so the 1st choice gets 4 points, the 2nd choice gets 3 points, etc. These Borda scores are then used as STAR ratings for tabulation by STAR.

STAR winner: MALIA COHEN
Finalists: MALIA COHEN vs TONY KELLY
Runoff result:
- MALIA COHEN: 8,869 votes (54.3%)
- TONY KELLY: 5,000 votes (30.6%)
- No preference: 2473 voters (15.1%)
Total stars allocated: 107,693
Total ballots: 16,342

★★★★★★

★★★★★

★★★★★★

★★★★★

★★★★★★

★★★★★

★★★★★★

★★★★★

★★★★★★

(one star above is approximately 2,154 stars allocated by voters)

First round:
- ★#0: MALIA COHEN received 38,154 stars (35.4%) from 10,622 voters (65.0%)
- ★#1: TONY KELLY received 25,916 stars (24.1%) from 8,038 voters (49.2%)
- ★#2: MARLENE TRAN received 19,921 stars (18.5%) from 6,189 voters (37.9%)
- ★#3: SHAWN M. RICHARD received 12,639 stars (11.7%) from 4,554 voters (27.9%)
- ★#4: ED DONALDSON received 11,063 stars (10.3%) from 3,866 voters (23.7%)
Finalists:
- ★MALIA COHEN (✅ winner) preferred by 8,869 of 16,342 voters
- ★TONY KELLY preferred by 5,000 of 16,342 voters
- ★No preference between the finalists: 2473

NOTE: Since ratings or stars are not present in the provided ballots, allocated stars are estimated using a Borda-like formula.

Voting methods: IRV • FPTP • approval • STAR • Pairwise • All methods

(homepage)

abif.electorama.com is maintained as part of the electorama.com family of websites.
Source code:


          github.com/electorama/abiftool

(for the core library) and github.com/electorama/awt (for the web presentation code)
Bug reports:


        
          github.com/electorama/awt/issues